Reviewer-1 Comments
Response: Cardiovascular responses in Physically Elderly Active People Living with HIV
Response: Done
Response: people living with HIV (PLHIV)
Response: Correct the word "identified"
Response: Done
Response: Conclusion: It appears that physically active participants are experiencing some degree of autonomic dysfunction. However, physical activity seems to help slow down common CV effects.
Response: Since PLHIV have a compromised immune system, they are at greater risk of developing CVD, especially with ineffective management of the modifiable risk factors associated with CVD.
Response: Common modifiable CVD risk factors include smoking, dyslipidemia, obesity, and a sedentary lifestyle
Response: Done
Response: Factors
Response: Fixed
Response: Fixed
Response: Fixed
Response: Fixed
Response: Fixed
Response: Done
Response: Done
Response: Done
Response: W.D. McArdle et al. (1972) Reliability and interrelationships between maximal oxygen uptake, physical work capacity and step test scores in college women. Medicine and Science in Sports, Vol 4, p182-186.
Response: Done
Response: Done
Response: Fixed
Response: Fixed
Response: isnt this a finding? When you work with population with any issues, such as cardiovascular, it is important to established baseline. What if meds or the virus are making these values change?
Response: In HIV people, cardiovascular responses to exercises are affected and HR could stay steady or slightly increase due to OH or others cardiometabolic complications. I don't see the issue in confirming this response, regardless of how basic it is. Those living with HIV also have profound balance problems which they hide or manage to compensate with visual input. Is testing for balance baseline a joke too?
Characteristics Study Participants n=11
Response: Done (Study Participants n=21)
Response: Done
Response: Done
29 : Table-2. Comparisons of resting heart rate among tasks. Results of repeated measures ANOVA performed comparing rest-HR among the other conditions. Significance level set at p≤0.01.
Response: Done
Response: Done
Reviewer-2 Comments
I have consulted some literature on the methods described in this article and there are no similarities.
I personally believe that the data was researched by the author himself.
The method described in the article has been validated in methodology and can meet the requirements.
Based on this, I personally believe that this article does not need to be modified, and your publication of this article can provide relevant readers with a hint of significance.
Response: Thank you for reviewing the article. I would like give my gratitude for their effort and hard work