FROM : Opening the Cultural Enigma to Survive: The ‘Gangster’ Adoption (Guddifachaa) Practices Experience of Orphaned Child in Arada Sub-City

Reviewer comment-1

The first reviewer has strong vested interest in focusing his/her view of the review on incumbent political issues in Ethiopia than the purpose of the research which is about recurrent social problems of orphan children and the use of locally resource to tackle which indirectly harmonized the gangster to mainstream society from becoming a burden to a solution in society. Hence, this research was conducted before the incumbent sensitive and fragile system was in place. This paper is important to focus on the assets and resources as well as continuing to advocate for solutions within the community as source of support for looming problems of orphans and flourishing gangster in that community.

Reviewer comment-2

This article explores the research on the adoption of orphans in the city of Addis Ababa (Finfinnee) in the rural area of Ethiopia.

This study uses in-depth interviews with a single gang leader man to study the adoption behavior with cultural characteristics and rituals, and at the same time reveals this A case that is different from the mystery of local adoption practices is a difficult study and the findings have implications.
Here are some suggestions for article content:
1. In the writing format of this article, chapters and paragraphs should be adjusted appropriately to comply with academic standards.
2. This article only uses one case for research. How to explain the universality of the results of this study.
This study is using a single case to study a vary rampant issue of orphan children’s problem and the gang problem in the study area. It is promoting good character in society through modeling
3. How to triangulate the interview data in this article to prove the reliability and validity of the interview data should be explained.

To discuss the validity of the data the researcher used techniques of observation, preliminary date from the household and the interaction of children on their natural setting
If the full score is 10, this article can get 7 points.